we took in a couple last summer. They were VERY cautious and nervous. They had never been paddling and had obviously never "camped" outside of a canadian tire style drive into a 15x15 lot in a provincial park with your car beside you.
A few key things I took into this trip:
- small water so wind wouldn't be as big as an issue as it could be on bigger water
- close to put in incase of emergency to get out
- possibly still within cell range
But I wanted to give them the best experience I could. This meant atleast a small portage to get atleast somewhat "remote" if not by distance atleast by feel.
We put in #4 Rain Lake and went down the lake and portaged to Sawyer and stayed there for two nights. It actually was a perfect trip. Although to me it felt like it wasn't even time yet for a snack break, we had reached our destination. The lake was great, we were swimming all day. I got a leech on my foot lol. At the end of it all, they both said what an amazing time they had and how they can't wait to go next year on a bigger trip.
I brought my canoe and we rented a canoe for them in Kearney, so we got to avoid the whole show at Canoe etc.
I take this approach with whoever new we are going in with. I ask what they want to accomplish and what will make them feel safe. Then assess their skillset and plan something to fit so everyone has a good time. If someone is pushed too hard, is miserable, is not comfortable, they likely wont return.