Offline
Curious if anyone has bought a dehydrator in the past few years with positive experiences.
My old Nesco crapped out on me -- it keeps blowing thermal fuses despite replacing. I've read less-than-optimistic reviews about newer Nesco models. The Excalibur dehydrators seem to have great reviews. There's also some others I've not heard of before such as Magic Mill.
I know some older dehydrators passed down from your grandma's grandma are probably alive and kicking... but I'm stuck buying in this modern market. Any insights are appreciated!
Offline
I'm on my 2nd Nesco but that's the 2nd over the course of 15-20 years. I may not use it as much as other folks, but I put a lot of hours on it prepping for my trip this summer and it never blinked.
Last edited by RobW (9/07/2023 1:21 pm)
Offline
I'm still on my first Nesco and it's been at least 15 years. I'm not a heavy user, but it's been solid.
Offline
Excalibur's are fantastic, I'll be upgrading to one if/when my Nesco craps out.
Offline
We have an Excalibur and love it, although it hasn't been used nearly as much as we had hoped (yet!).
Last edited by hiker72 (9/08/2023 6:02 am)
Offline
I have an Excalibur. Seems great but was our first so nothing to compare it to. Gets the job done.
Offline
How's the Excalibur for dehydrating chili, stew, or other saucy dishes?
With the nesco, I had used additional fruit leather trays on the bottom-most racks to capture the liquids of the dishes. It worked well as these trays would end up as a leather of the sauce. Does the Excalibur have a similar arrangement that allows it to dehydrate such meals?
Thread StarterOffline
Zemantics wrote:
How's the Excalibur for dehydrating chili, stew, or other saucy dishes?
With the nesco, I had used additional fruit leather trays on the bottom-most racks to capture the liquids of the dishes. It worked well as these trays would end up as a leather of the sauce. Does the Excalibur have a similar arrangement that allows it to dehydrate such meals?
The unit we purchased did not come with solid racks or mats, so we had to buy a separate package of silicone dehydrator mats. Unfortunately, I haven't tried dehydrating saucy dishes yet, so I'm equally curious as to how that will turn out...
Offline
How's the Excalibur for dehydrating chili, stew, or other saucy dishes?
With the nesco, I had used additional fruit leather trays on the bottom-most racks to capture the liquids of the dishes. It worked well as these trays would end up as a leather of the sauce. Does the Excalibur have a similar arrangement that allows it to dehydrate such meals?The unit we purchased did not come with solid racks or mats, so we had to buy a separate package of silicone dehydrator mats. Unfortunately, I haven't tried dehydrating saucy dishes yet, so I'm equally curious as to how that will turn out...
That'd definitely be a deal breaker for me to hear negative reviews on that front. The nesco was solid for a good ten years for me in that regard. The last customer service convo I had with them where I explained having replaced a Thermo resistor several times and their solution was a new power head kinda ticked me off
Thread StarterOffline
I like my excalibur. I have successfully dehydrated spaghetti sauce and chili using parchment paper - not very watery sauces but definately wet.
How's the Excalibur for dehydrating chili, stew, or other saucy dishes?
With the nesco, I had used additional fruit leather trays on the bottom-most racks to capture the liquids of the dishes. It worked well as these trays would end up as a leather of the sauce. Does the Excalibur have a similar arrangement that allows it to dehydrate such meals?The unit we purchased did not come with solid racks or mats, so we had to buy a separate package of silicone dehydrator mats. Unfortunately, I haven't tried dehydrating saucy dishes yet, so I'm equally curious as to how that will turn out...
That'd definitely be a deal breaker for me to hear negative reviews on that front. The nesco was solid for a good ten years for me in that regard. The last customer service convo I had with them where I explained having replaced a Thermo resistor several times and their solution was a new power head kinda ticked me off
Offline
Works great for chili imo. Definitely requires some cleanup but it's does a great job. I can fit a decent sized crackpot worth at once. Enough to feed 6 .
Offline
Thanks guys. What size of Excalibur do you have?
Thread Starter
1 of 1