Great report. A lot of the 'dumb decisions' were justifiable at least, even if they weren't the smartest choices (i.e. not wanting to portage when the sun is on its final minutes).
The only thing that I don't get is why you decided to leave Burntroot. You mentioned that you got to the east site midway down the lake at noon, and you got to the Perley site at 6pm, meaning you must have spent about 4hrs resting on Burntroot. After that long, and when it's already 4pm or so, there's no way I would leave!
On the plus side, these adventures always make for the better stories... as long as you come out alive
Trip Reports & Campsite Pictures
algonquinbeyond.com