Methye wrote:
Okay this one will get me in trouble, because they seem very common, but...who thought packing food in a heavy blue barrel would be a good idea? It's heavy, and provides no protection from a determined bear. It doesn't protect your food from breakage, because of course your food is packed in soft containers or ziplocs. Requires a special harness. Always see poor German tourists trying to tote these heavy bulky things around because they are told that is what you must do. I've never understood the appeal.
I bring the barrel whenever it makes sense. If I'm going solo for 2-3 nights, there's no point in filling a barrel 1/5th of the way and bringing it along. But I like the barrel because it's practically scent proof compared to a dry pack. Yes a bear can still get into barrels, but the idea is that they won't be attracted to it in the first place. And if it's hung properly, they'll have a hard time getting to it anyways. I definitely feel more comfortable when I have the barrel, especially if I'm bringing smelly foods like sausage, etc.
I don't really care about food breakage since I've never had that issue with any of the foods I bring. The one thing I dislike about the barrel is that it doesn't get smaller as you eat, like a pack would.
If it was between single carrying or bringing the barrel, I wouldn't bring it; but if I'm able to bring it without it affecting my portaging, I'll bring it.
Trip Reports & Campsite Pictures
algonquinbeyond.com